Skip to content
Save 50% on Flooring
Serving Central Indiana Call (317) 721-8022
TFPros - Transitional Flooring Professionals
Wood-look laminate and luxury vinyl plank samples side by side
Material Guides

Laminate or Luxury Vinyl Plank? How to Choose Room by Room

Both are click-together, wood-look and sold as waterproof. The differences show up in the details: what the core is made of, how the surface handles claws and chair legs, and how each one sounds and feels.

· 7 min read

Laminate and luxury vinyl plank are the two floors people mix up most at our consultations. Both click together and float over an underlayment, both come in convincing wood looks, and the better lines of both are sold as waterproof. Lay a plank of each on the kitchen table and most people cannot tell which is which. They are different products, though, and the differences decide which one belongs in your mudroom, your basement or your upstairs bedrooms. This guide compares them on the points that matter in a central Indiana house, then goes room by room.

What each one is made of

Laminate is a wood-based product. A dense fiberboard core carries a printed image of wood, and a hard, clear wear layer sits on top. The waterproof laminate we install adds a water-resistant core and sealed, tight-locking edges, and the better lines emboss the surface grain to line up with the print underneath, so the texture follows the pattern you see.

Luxury vinyl plank is a plastic-based product. The core is either a rigid stone-plastic composite (SPC) or a thicker, softer wood-plastic composite (WPC), with a printed layer and a clear vinyl wear layer on top. Because vinyl does not absorb water, the plank itself is waterproof all the way through. SPC vs WPC covers the two core types.

Water: both handle spills, LVP handles more

For the everyday kitchen spill or a dog's water bowl, a good waterproof laminate and a good LVP both do the job, as long as you wipe the water up. The difference shows with standing water and time. A vinyl plank does not take on water at all. A laminate core resists it for the period the manufacturer states, and the warranty spells out how long that is and under what conditions.

That is why we lean toward LVP for full bathrooms, laundry rooms and basements on a slab, where water can sit unnoticed or come up from below. Bathroom and laundry room flooring and waterproof basement flooring go further on those rooms.

Scratches and dents

Laminate's top layer is harder than a vinyl wear layer. Premium laminate lines carry abrasion ratings of AC4 or AC5, the same scale used for commercial floors, and they shrug off grit, dog claws and dragged chairs well. If scratches are your main worry and the room stays mostly dry, laminate is hard to beat.

Vinyl is a little softer on the surface, so it takes fine scuffs more readily, but it gives under a point load and springs back. Rigid-core LVP resists dents from furniture feet better than most people expect. Heavy, narrow loads still dent anything, so put felt pads or wide cups under furniture legs on either floor. Flooring for pets and kids compares both for busy households.

Sound and feel underfoot

Laminate is the harder, stiffer floor, and on a poor underlayment it can sound hollow and clicky when you walk on it in shoes. A good attached or separate underlayment fixes most of that. LVP, especially with an attached pad, tends to sound softer and feel a touch warmer underfoot, which some people prefer in bedrooms and upstairs rooms.

If the floor goes upstairs over living space, the underlayment matters as much as the plank. Quiet floors explains footstep noise and what helps.

Subfloors, sunlight and heat

Both floors float, and both need a flat subfloor. A dip or hump that a carpet pad would hide shows up as a soft spot, a gap or a plank that rocks. We check flatness before either one goes down. Subfloor prep covers what that involves.

Vinyl reacts more to heat than laminate does. In a sunroom or in front of a large south or west window, a vinyl floor can get hot enough to expand and move, so the product has to be rated for that location. Laminate handles direct sun better on that front, though any printed floor can fade over years. Floors in sunny rooms covers both.

Room by room

Kitchen: either works. Pick laminate for the harder surface if spills get wiped quickly. Pick LVP if a dishwasher or sink leak would worry you. Mudroom and entry: laminate's hard top layer handles salt and grit well, LVP handles wet boots sitting on it for hours. Entryway and mudroom flooring weighs that up.

Full bathrooms, laundry rooms and basements: LVP, because water there can sit unseen. Living rooms, hallways and bedrooms: either one, chosen on look, feel and sound. Sunrooms: check the specific product's heat and sun rating before anything else.

Many houses end up with both: LVP in the wet rooms and a matching laminate through the main living space, or one product throughout for a continuous look. If you go that route, plan the transitions so the heights line up. Where two floors meet shows how.

See them side by side in your own rooms

Store lighting makes every floor look good. Your kitchen at 7 a.m. in January is the real test. At a free in-home consultation we bring luxury vinyl plank and waterproof laminate samples to your house so you can stand on them, drop your keys on them and see them next to your cabinets.

We install across Indianapolis, Fishers, Avon and the surrounding counties. Book a free in-home consultation and tell us which rooms you are doing. We will recommend one floor or the other for each room, and tell you why.

Frequently asked questions

Is laminate or luxury vinyl plank better?
Neither wins everywhere. Laminate has a harder, more scratch-resistant top layer and handles sun and heat well. Luxury vinyl plank is waterproof through the whole plank, so it suits full bathrooms, laundry rooms and basements where water can sit. Many homes use both, chosen room by room.
Is waterproof laminate really waterproof?
Waterproof laminate resists surface water for the length of time its manufacturer states, as long as the water is cleaned up. A vinyl plank does not absorb water at all. For rooms where water can sit unnoticed, luxury vinyl plank is the safer choice.
Which scratches less, laminate or LVP?
Laminate, as a rule. Premium laminate carries an AC4 or AC5 abrasion rating and resists grit and claws well. Vinyl's wear layer is softer and takes fine scuffs more readily, though rigid-core LVP resists dents well.
Which is quieter, laminate or luxury vinyl plank?
LVP usually sounds softer underfoot, especially with an attached pad. Laminate can sound hollow over a thin underlayment. On either floor, a good underlayment makes the biggest difference, particularly upstairs.
Ready when you are

Book a free in-home design consultation.

Factory-direct pricing across Indianapolis, Carmel, Fishers, and the surrounding metro. Quick installs of upper-end USA products - most projects wrap in 1 to 2 weeks, backed by a 1-year labor warranty plus the manufacturer's lifetime warranty - up to a 50-year hard surface lifespan.

Google Reviews

What homeowners say about working with TFPros.

JM
Janna Marie
Greater Indianapolis

"Highly recommend! Julio was very professional and knowledgeable when he came out to give us an estimate. We chose the carpet we wanted and could not be happier with the service TFP provided. The installers were hard workers and very respectful of our home."

Google Review
AB
Addison Broady
Greater Indianapolis

"Very happy with the work of this company on my new hardwood floors. Everything looks seamless and the crew was wonderful to work with. Great guys! Would recommend and use them again for any of my flooring needs."

Google Review
AT
Addison Taylor
Greater Indianapolis

"I recently had these guys out to replace some old carpet. Was surprised by the friendliness of the employees as well as the quality of the service. Great crew that does a great job!"

Google Review
AC
Andrew Carr
Greater Indianapolis

"Good crew, fast and efficient. They handled glued laminate and carpet demolition, then installed LVP. Overall, satisfied with the results. I would use them again."

Google Review
JH
Jacob Harrison
Greater Indianapolis

"Great crew, they paid good attention to detail and delivered as promised."

Google Review